Sketching Out Blog: Sketches of art, watercolor, photos, recipes, books, interviews, Jewish topics, and Highland Park, New Jersey

Shavuot When One Learns All the Jews in One’s Town Were Killed

Rhododendron in bloom, May 2009
Rhododendron in bloom, May 2009
What do blooming garden flowers and the shocker I used for a title have in common?

In S. Y. Agnon’s short story “The Sign” the main character learns that all the Jews in his hometown in Europe have been killed by the Nazis. He learns this at the same time his house in the Land of Israel has been decorated for Shavuot in the traditional way, with flowers and plants:

The sun shone down on the outside of the house; inside, on the walls, we had hung cypress, pine, and laurel branches, and flowers. Each beautiful flower and everything with a sweet smell and been brought in to decorate the house for the holiday of Shavuot. In all the days I had lived in the Land of Israel, our house had never been decorated so nicely as it was that day. All the flaws in the house had vanished, and not a crack was to be seen, either in the ceiling or in the walls. From the places where the cracks in the house used to gape with open mouths and laugh at the builders, there came instead the pleasant smell of branches and shrubs, and especially of the flowers we had brought from our garden. These humble creatures, which because of their great modesty don’t raise themselves high above the ground except to give off their good smell, made the eye rejoice because of the many colors with which the Holy One, blessed be He, has decorated them, to glorify His land, which, in His loving-kindness, He has given to us.

A little later in the story Agnon teaches us a little of the halachot (laws) of Shavuot:

Although on the Sabbath and festivals one says the evening prayers early, on Shavuot we wait to say Maariv until the stars are out.

For if we were to pray early and recieve the holiness of the festival, we would be shortening the days of the Omer, and the Torah said, “There shall be seven full weeks.”

Later, the main character is standing in the synagogue, facing the six memorial candles shining among the roses and the wildflowers and the garden flowers that have been used to decorate the sanctuary. “Is it possible that a city full of Torah and life is suddenly uprooted from the world, and all its people—old and young; men, women and children—are killed, that now the city is silent, with not a soul of Israel left in it?”

Who is S. Y. Agnon? Shmuel Yosef Agnon was born Shmuel Yosef Czaczkes in Buczacz, Galicia. In 1908 he immigrated to Israel and in 1913 he went to Germany, where he married his wife. He returned to Israel in 1924. If you have heard of Saul Bellow or Isaac Bashevis Singer, S. Y. Agnon won the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1966, years before Saul Bellow and Isaac Bashevis Singer won their Nobel Prizes. Agnon wrote his stories in Hebrew, one of the first modern writers to do so. I hope one day to read his stories in Hebrew, as one loses a lot in translation.

Many thanks to Lorri (Rayna Elianna) for recommending A Book That Was Lost: Thirty Five Stories (Hebrew Classics),a lovely book of short stories. The holiday of Shavuot, which is a major Jewish holiday (as opposed to say, Chanukah, which is only a minor holiday) begins on Thursday night, May 28th. It is traditional to decorate one’s home with flowers, to stay up all night learning Torah, and to eat dairy dishes (we’ll be having ice cream for dessert).

Ilana-Davita says

Fine choice of extracts before the holiday. I ordered this book after you recommended it, except the book is at home while I am not.

ramblingwoods says

Thank you for the education I am getting...

Leora says

Quiz at 11...:-)
(because I am curious what you are learning?)

Devo K says

I see you'll be hostessing the next JPix. I seem to have been left out of the last 2 - I filled out the blog carnival form so I was wondering if I should email the info to you directly or fill out the carnival form.

phyllis says

great choice of story - thanks for reminding me that i already own this book!:-) chag sameach...

Jew Wishes/Lorri says

The flowers are beautiful, such wonderful tones and contrasts, and so dainty looking, such prettiness.

Agnon's writing is beautiful, intense and thought-provoking. I loved this book, as you well know. Thanks for the link, Leora!

I remember reading that Saul Bellow had once stated something somewhat negative regarding Agnon's writing. I disagree.

Leora says

From the preface:
'Bellow says of Agnon:
"Entirely immersed in Hebrew and Yiddish literature, he apparently has little interest in Western literary traditions."...the falseness of this comment is staggering...'

Guess Bellow was a tad bit jealous.

Klara Le Vine says

My husband, who came here in high school and has a good command of Hebrew, has been fascinated by Agnon and has been going through all his books in the original Hebrew. He can't rave enough how his use of Hebrew is so beautiful as well as his command of so much Biblical references. However, he reads it with the book in one hand and a dictionary in the other!!!! He says it gets easier as he reads more and more. Good luck to you, Leora.

Leora says

I am now reading Only Yesterday by S. Y. Agnon. I thought it would be difficult reading, but I am sailing through the book! (won't have much time to read until next weekend, but that's another story). I identify with the main character in some ways, who is very idealistic in his youth and grapples with reality when it comes.

It was nice meeting your husband, and I am glad we share a fascination with Agnon in common. I look forward to reading some of Agnon's short stories in Hebrew.


Please leave a comment! I love to hear from you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.